Reflections on time spent wearing a pedometer
Earlier this year when John and I were in Cleveland visiting my folks, my Dad gave me his spare pedometer to try out. The Cleveland Clinic has started doing a fitness/nutrition program for its employees, and my parents both signed up to participate, and my Dad ended up with an extra pedometer, which he passed on to me.
I think of myself as a pretty fit and active person – I go to yoga class on the weekends (usually both Saturday and Sunday), I fence at least once a week, and I do cardio (running on the elliptical and/or treadmill) and use the weight machines at the gym at work during the week. (I have found that a workout sometime around mid-afternoon is great for clearing my head and thinking, and is also the guaranteed quietest time at the gym at work.) So I figured that wearing the pedometer would be a good way to have hard numbers to confirm my own impressions of my fitness level.
According to the little instruction manual, 10,000 steps a day is an indicator of an “active” lifestyle. Anything below that is some variation of a “sedentary” lifestyle. I figured that I should easily average somewhere between 9,000-10,000 steps a day.
The big shock was that unless I was doing a cardio workout of at least 45 minutes that day, I would average only around 4,000 steps. Days where I ran on the elliptical/treadmill were the only days where I hit or surpassed the 10,000 steps-a-day goal. So I sit more and walk a hell of a lot less ten I thought that I did. Which I guess should have been no big surprise since I work at a computer 8 hours a day. But still.
Granted, the pedometer didn’t register about half of my workouts – the yoga, the weight machines, and the fencing. There is not a lot of walking around involved when you are doing yoga or on a weight machine. And there was just too much jumping around and too many erratic movements for the pedometer to accurately track anything during fencing. (Also, after the first time I stopped wearing it to fencing practice since I was worried that it would get hit by a blade and break.)
So is the pedometer a good way of measuring fitness? Eh, I dunno. I am going to keep wearing it, certainly (because I love numbers and data) but I think that I will be taking my daily numbers and averaging them out over the week, and shoot for an average of 8,000 steps a day, regardless of other types of workouts. That seems to be more reasonable to me then kicking myself on a daily basis because it is so difficult (as a suburban-living, desk-bound, computer-jockey) to hit the daily goal of 10,000 steps.
I don’t trust pedometers. I’ve had several different kinds, both cheap and expensive. Most of them don’t seem to register all the steps you take. One lap through the building at work is a mile, and I’ve found as many as half my steps missing.
Parsla
12 Feb 11 at 6:46 am
I just happened to stumble across your website and the article Reflections on time spent wearing a pedometer at Infogirl. The words you give kind of causes me think. Thanks for sharing.
Trista Leek
6 Mar 12 at 12:50 am